Restaurants

Old Farm Inn

4.3 126 reviews Closed 1656 Plank Rd, Carrolltown, PA 15722, United States

Discover this place

Old Farm Inn, nestled in Carrolltown, PA, is a charming, family-owned bar and restaurant that offers a delightful dining experience. With its cozy atmosphere, patrons rave about its hearty menu, featuring standout items like stromboli, burgers, and their renowned Buffalo chicken fries. Diners consistently highlight the generous portions and reasonable pricing, making it a great spot for families and a perfect place to savor delicious comfort food.

Many reviews express admiration for the fresh ingredients used in every dish, from the homemade fries to the grilled chicken salads. The local sourcing of meats and vegetables adds a touch of authenticity and taste that keeps customers returning. Patrons also appreciate the friendly service, which enhances the overall experience. Despite its small size and modest decor, Old Farm Inn is celebrated as a hidden gem where every meal is crafted with care.

With its ice cold draft beer and a welcoming vibe, Old Farm Inn proves to be a must-visit destination for those seeking quality food and a sense of community. For anyone exploring local dining options, this establishment is not to be missed!

Photos

Amenities & More

Service options

Delivery
Takeout
Dine-in

Highlights

Fast service
Great beer selection
Serves local specialty
Sports

Popular for

Lunch
Dinner
Solo dining

Dining options

Lunch
Dinner
Dessert
Seating
Table service

Amenities

Bar onsite
Restroom

Atmosphere

Casual
Cozy
Quiet

Crowd

Groups
Tourists

Note: Amenity details are aggregated from verified visits, the venue's website and Google. They may change without notice. We recommend confirming key details (pet policy, accessibility, reservations) directly with Old Farm Inn before visiting.

Reviews for Old Farm Inn

4.3

126 reviews

100%

33%

11%

Review highlights

Based on 126 reviews

Old Farm Inn is frequently praised for its welcoming, family-owned atmosphere and classic small-town charm. Reviewers highlight the consistently fresh and well-prepared menu, featuring generously portioned dishes such as stromboli, burgers, sandwiches, and homemade fries. The emphasis on locally sourced ingredients and made-to-order meals contributes to the overall positive dining experience. Customers also appreciate the friendly and accommodating staff, noted for attentive service and a personable approach. While the establishment is described as modest and somewhat rustic in appearance, this does not detract from the quality of food and warm hospitality. The availability of cold draft beers complements the hearty, comfort-style fare, making it a favored local spot for both families and casual diners. Overall, Old Farm Inn is recognized for delivering good value, reliable food quality, and a cozy environment that encourages repeat visits.

Magnesium Linoleum

Jun 14, 2025

Great family-owened old school bar and restaurant. Very good stromboli, bugers, sandwiches, and ice cold draft beer. Fine for families. Please patronize locally-owned restaurants!

Robb Forobough

Jun 03, 2025

Just a GREAT... bar/restaurant. VG food with good prices/portions BIG. Cold beer. Moms coleslaw too. Pizza/Stromboli... I will be back... again FASTASTIC... fries. The BEST. Wait till U try em. Home made fresh Cut m... fries. Ice COLD beer too.

Jesse Hott

May 26, 2025

We've only been going there for about a year and it's always a great experience. While it's a small establishment, the food is really good, of a great proportion, and at an even greater price! The crew are awesome and helpful!

JODI SAVAGE

May 10, 2025

The food here is awesome!! They use all fresh vegetables, meats, all ingredients!! Everything is cooked well to your preference!! I like my meat cooked extra well done, request as such...done as ask!! My favorite is their grilled chicken salads!! All their food is very good!! Definitely recommend!!

Tanya Williams

May 03, 2025

This is a very small and a little run-down place, but my husband and I loved it. We have only gone two times so far, but did not have a bad experience either time. The first time was just my husband and I. The waitress recommended the Buffalo chicken fries, so we got them. We each got a burger (which they get locally), and since they come Ala cart, we figured why not. These fries came out on a huge platter smothered in chicken, cheese, and so much gooey goodness. They were AWESOME! We could not finish since we also ordered breaded mushrooms and cheese curds as well. No idea there would be so many fries. They are very good reheated too...surprising for fries. The burgers were also excellent. Fresh made patties, not frozen. This place is definitely a hidden gem. We took my son this past weekend, and he loved it as well.

Pam Covel

Apr 11, 2025

Very friendly service. The food is delicious and you get a big serving of whatever you order. The prices are reasonable. We really enjoyed our meal.

Elizabeth Harkleroad

Mar 07, 2025

Great food, fast service only downfall is the booth bench seats are half dead but Great place

Morgan Sanderson

Mar 05, 2025

I love this restaurant. They make THE BEST pizza in the area, and you get so much food for what you pay! The owners are so kind, too. If you're near Carrolltown, this is the place to go!